Searching for the most comfortable pillow can seem like an endless quest. Even if you did have the time to go to each store where a different pillow was available, you still wouldn’t be able to determine the most comfortable pillow for you. According to the associate professor of physiotherapy at James Cook University, Susan Gordon:  “You will need a week sleeping on a pillow" if you want to find out if it will work out for you.

Under those circumstances, it may be a good idea to inquire about the return policy before investing in your pillow. Therefore, if the manufacturer provides a warranty for any of these pillows, we will include it.

Comfort is subjective and can mean many different things to different people. Some people find a flat feather pillow to be the most comfortable pillow. Others may opt for a firm or even a hard pillow. Besides the filler, there are other factors that will determine which will be the most comfortable pillow for you.

Person hugging a white pillow

How Sleeping Position Affects Your Comfort

The position you sleep in can have an impact on which pillow you will find most comfortable. You have to support your head and neck differently when you sleep in different positions. Here is a brief rundown of which pillows should be best for each recommended position.

The side sleeper

According to a survey performed by Consumer Reports, nearly 70 percent of people sleep on their side. For these people, a firmer pillow is best to support the neck. A firm pillow prevents the head from bending downward and misaligning the spine. For this reason, pillows filled with memory foam, latex, or buckwheat husks offer the best support without spine displacement. A contoured pillow can also be incorporated to provide additional support to the neck without misaligning the spine. However, side-sleepers should avoid polyester and down or feather pillows.

Note that most memory foam and chemically created material may have a bit of an odor upon being removed from their packaging. A brief time exposed to air should dissipate this aroma quickly.

The back sleeper

Back sleepers face a different challenge because gravity can have more of an impact on your sleep. If you use a pillow with too much support, it can force your head upward. This not only creates a curved spine but also causes breathing problems. It can exacerbate issues such as snoring, post nasal drip, and sleep apnea, a malady in which someone momentarily stops breathing. The tongue can be pulled back by gravity and block a person’s airway.

For these reasons, back-sleepers are encouraged to use medium-firm pillows. Fillers of down, memory foam, latex, or buckwheat husks are usually best for this type of sleeper.

The stomach sleeper

Stomach sleeping is the position fraught with the most issues. Because you are face down, a pillow of even moderate firmness will force your head upward, thereby bowing the spine. For this reason, experts recommend pillows filled down feathers, polyester, or soft synthetics.  A thin layer between you and the mattress will prevent your neck from tilting backward and causing you pain upon awakening.

The flopper

If you are a person who tends to shift position all night, the most comfortable pillow for you will likely be one that has soft and firm sections. Several pillows are available that fit that description, including some with very distinct sections of soft and firm. Buckwheat hull pillows are firm enough to offer all-around support, yet pliable enough to accommodate to your position as needed.

Five white pillows sitting on a bed

How We Made This List

As mentioned earlier, naming one pillow as “the most comfortable pillow” simply isn’t possible. People have varying criteria for what they consider comfortable. Rather than try to narrow down the choices to just one and a few runners-up, we will present the best from several different categories.

Personal Preferences

You may already have a personal preference for comfortable pillows. Excluding medical situations, where you need a specific kind of orthopedic pillow for comfort, you should be able to find some on this list that you feel warrant further investigation.

Choosing the Most Comfortable Pillow

These days, pillows come in many shapes, sizes, and filler. From old favorites like feather pillows to some made of materials that never existed until relatively recently. For the most part, each of these pillows will have its own pros and cons. Like Goldilocks, you may have to do a little research before you find the one that feels “just right.” With that in mind, we've identified the most comfortable pillows below, in no particular order.

The familiar purple grid pattern, also found in their popular Purple Mattress, offers many of the same features in the Purple Pillow. Excellent support, temperature control, and air circulation are all here in this hypoallergenic product made in America by the Purple company. Not only does it conform to your neck and head while still retaining its shape, but it also includes a “booster” that allows you to adjust the loft (height) of the pillow. The pillow cover contains bamboo viscose, spandex, and polyester to also keep you cool and comfortable.

A highly recommended pillow for back sleepers because of its easy compression, the Purple Pillow also conforms to the shape of your neck and head for greater support. For everyone else, it offers the exceptional cooling properties of the latex-like polymer construction. The Purple Pillow is firm at the edge and soft in the middle. This provides a comfortable sleep to almost any restless sleeper.

Besides the fact that you never have to flip this pillow over to find the cool side, consumers were also pleased that the price includes free shipping and a full 100-day money back guarantee. 

Beans72 Organic Buckwheat Pillow - Japanese Size (14 inches x 20...
  • Filling: 100% US Grown Organic Buckwheat Hulls. Casing: 100% Natural Unbleached Cotton.
  • May relieve common sleeping problems such as; tension, muscle pain, stiff neck, headache and stress
  • Will conform and adjust perfectly to your head, neck, and spine. Will NOT collapse like foam.

If your goal is to get better sleep, you will love the Beans72 organic buckwheat pillow. Besides being comfortable, cool, and easily shaped, the Beans72 buckwheat fill has the desirable properties of eliminating several of the things preventing you for getting a good night’s sleep. Ambient noise, neck and back discomfort, allergies, or the heat that can build up between your head and your foam pillow. The buckwheat husk solves these issues by virtue of the buckwheat husk filler. Comprised of thousands and thousands of individual hulls, this pillow can be made harder or softer simply by adding or removing the hulls.

You can form the Beans72 into any shape you like just by moving the hulls around inside the pillow. If you ever felt the need to clean it, you can pour out the hulls and rinse them in clean water. The pillow cover is machine washable and once dry the hulls can be returned to your pillow. Some customers reported cleaning them with scented water for an extra fresh smell.

The Coop Home Goods company only makes a single pillow. Fortunately, it’s a very good one. The Coop Pillow is shredded memory foam. This provides comfort and support. It comes in three sizes. Standard, Queen, and King size. Manufactured in the US, it has a 40 percent bamboo cover and the fill consists of CertiPUR-US Certified Foam. The Coop Pillow comes with a full five-year warranty and is completely machine washable.

Xtreme Comforts - Slim Kool-Flow Bamboo Shredded Memory Foam Bed...
  • "The best bed pillow" ★ rated #1 by the wirecutter an independent review organization. USA today voted 2019 best...
  • Our memory foam pillows use only certipur-us certified foam & meet stringent standards for content, emissions &...
  • Ultra deluxe premium quality shredded memory foam will not get lumpy or go flat. It remains uniform in density,...

A mighty long name for a mighty comfortable pillow, the Xtreme Comforts slim hypoallergenic bamboo shredded CertiPUR memory foam pillow, while designed for relieving neck and back pain, is a cozy pillow indeed. It maintains your head and neck in a very comfortable position while you sleep.

Because shredded pieces of memory foam do not flatten out, and you can adjust them within the pillow, it can cradle your head and neck. Completely machine washable, the cover features 43 percent bamboo to keep you cool. The Xtreme Comforts also comes with a moderate price and a money-back guarantee.

MALOUF Z Shoulder Zoned Dough Memory Foam Pillow - Gel Infused -...
  • Zoned dough memory foam is infused with gel to create a cooler, softer sleep environment
  • Unique shoulder recess designed specifically for side sleepers to eliminate tossing and turning
  • Zoned technology cradles head and supports neck while promoting airflow for cooler rest

Another pillow with a long name and a great reputation. Sweating into your pillow can prevent you from having a good night’s sleep. The design of the Malouf Z pillow gives side sleepers support of the neck, shoulders, and head in various degrees. Infused with bamboo charcoal, Zoned Dough® memory foam, and a breathable Tencel® Cover, the Malouf Z will keep you cool and sleeping comfortably all night.

Snuggle-Pedic Memory Foam Pillow - Adjustable Shredded Foam Sleeping...
  • Adjustable & Conforming Shape: Luxury bed pillows for sleeping on back, stomach, and side.
  • Memory Foam Fill Bag: You can add or remove the amount of shredded memory foam for your comfort via its easy, zipper...
  • Premium Fabric: The bamboo pillow for sleeping is crafted from luxurious high-quality shredded memory foam and has...

Come on. It has the work “Snuggle” right in the name. It had better be comfortable. Not to worry, the Snuggle-Pedic ultra-luxury bamboo Shredded Memory Foam Pillow offers all the comfort of a typical feather pillow without the head compression that can quickly make your feather pillow flat. Constructed of memory foam fill conforms to the shape of your neck and head. This offers very even and very consistent support. Covered with a Kool-Flow Soft micro-vented cover built out of bamboo, polyester, and Lycra, this cover lets air circulate and keeps your head cool while providing excellent support.

No products found.

No products found.

Sometimes you just can’t seem to get to sleep because you can’t get your pillow just right. The Sweetnight pillow is not just adjustable but virtually fine-tunable. By removing or adding foam stuffing you can easily adapt it to your personal sleeping preferences. Constructed with 90 percent shredded gel memory foam and 10 percent comfort foam, the Sweetnight also has a gel cover that will keep you extra cool on those warm nights.

Nature's Guest Cervical Pillow, Contour Orthopedic Support and...
  • CHIROPRACTOR AND ORTHOPEDIC RECOMMENDED DESIGN – Proven contoured pillow design (Patent Pending) helps reduce neck,...
  • FULLY ADJUSTABLE – Dual zipper design provides full access to pillow filling. Adjust to your desired firmness in both...

If you are not always a back sleeper or a side sleeper, you fall into that “undecided” category. This means you'll find it twice as hard to find a comfortable pillow. Well, look no further than the Nature’s Guest cervical support pillow. Constructed of microfiber and with a contour shape that will keep you comfortable no matter how you sleep. Highly recommended by the people who own one, this unique pillow provides neck support for side sleepers without forcing the heads of back sleepers upward. The Nature’s Guest pillow is another fully adjustable pillow for that final tweak that makes it perfect for you.

Time to Get the Most Comfortable Pillow for Better Quality Sleep

A bunch of pillows sitting on a bed

Finding the best pillow should only be about the most comfortable pillow for you. Fortunately, there are several models available that cover a wide range of preferences from feathers to foam, and from microfiber to buckwheat hulls. Always do your research but remember that nobody will be able to recommend the most comfortable pillow for you. You will have to search it out and give it a try for yourself. Hopefully, we have given you a place to start in your search. Sweet dreams!

Last update on 2021-05-08 at 10:00 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here